Eicher Motors shares saw a 2% rise in early Tuesday trade as multiple brokerages offered varied outlooks following the company's September quarter performance review. While some maintained positive stances, Nomura notably reduced its target price, citing valuation concerns and potential industry risks.
Brokerages Offer Mixed Views on Eicher Motors
Nomura maintained its 'Neutral' rating on Eicher Motors, lowering its target price to Rs 8,022 from a previous Rs 8,437. The brokerage highlighted that Eicher's September quarter EBITDA margin of 23.7% fell short of both its own estimate of 25% and the consensus estimate of 24%. Nomura also pointed to risks stemming from regulations concerning internal combustion engine vehicles and CAFE norms, alongside a potential consumer shift towards electric vehicles and scooters.
In contrast, Nirmal Bang reaffirmed its 'Buy' rating for Eicher Motors, increasing its target price to Rs 9,503 from Rs 8,888. Equirus Securities also maintained its 'Long' recommendation, setting a target price of Rs 9,533. Both brokerages acknowledged robust demand for Royal Enfield motorcycles, healthy booking momentum, and ongoing capacity expansion efforts.
Q2 Performance and Market Dynamics
Eicher Motors reported a steady second-quarter performance, with consolidated revenue climbing 20.3% year-on-year to Rs 74.2 billion, largely aligning with expectations. Royal Enfield motorcycle volumes reached 376,722 units, marking a 15.2% increase year-on-year.
Despite strong revenue growth, the company's gross margin contracted by 171 basis points year-on-year to 42% due to commodity inflation. EBITDA grew 16.4% to Rs 17.6 billion, but the EBITDA margin moderated by 79 basis points to 23.7%. Adjusted profit after tax rose 14.9% year-on-year to Rs 15.7 billion.
Demand and Supply Outlook
Brokerages noted strong underlying demand, with bookings and inquiries up approximately 20-21% year-to-date. However, festive season retail sales were constrained by limited supply, leading to low channel inventory of just seven to eight days, significantly below the normal three to four weeks. Nomura projects Royal Enfield to achieve around 13% volume growth between FY27 and FY29, supported by the anticipated launch of a new 250cc motorcycle, though it cautiously assesses the sales potential for this new segment.
Exports also showed signs of recovery, growing 12% year-on-year in the quarter after three consecutive quarters of decline. This improvement was largely driven by increased traction in Latin America, particularly Brazil, and emerging recovery signals in the US market.