Senior Supreme Court advocate Kapil Sibal has publicly questioned Venu Srinivasan's assertion that assets central to the ongoing TVS family dispute are his personal property. Sibal, who will represent Lakshmi Venu and her mother Mallika Srinivasan, argued that the businesses are generational and not solely Srinivasan's creation.
During an interview with Business Today, Sibal stated that the assets belong to the family, emphasizing that both Sudarshan Venu and Lakshmi Venu are entitled to an equal share. He highlighted that the dispute reflects broader patriarchal attitudes prevalent in some Indian business families, where a father might claim sole ownership over family-inherited wealth.
Sibal Challenges Srinivasan's Personal Property Claim
Kapil Sibal underscored that the TVS business was established by Srinivasan's great-grandfather in 1911 and has been built across generations. He challenged the idea that Venu Srinivasan could consider it his personal creation, especially when inherited. Lakshmi Venu, Chairman Emeritus of TVS Motor's daughter, has served a partition notice seeking an equal share of her branch's family assets under the Hindu Succession Act, a move supported by her mother, Mallika Srinivasan.
Venu Srinivasan, however, maintains that the assets are his personal property and asserts that both his children were treated fairly. Sibal alleged that Lakshmi Venu discovered through media reports that approximately 95% of the family business had been allocated to her brother, Sudarshan Venu, prompting her to seek clarity and equitable division.
The Hindu Succession Act and Daughters' Rights
Sibal cited crucial changes in inheritance laws, emphasizing that daughters now hold equal rights in joint family property. He specifically referenced a 1989 Tamil Nadu law and the 2005 parliamentary amendment, which established daughters as equal shareholders in coparcenary property. Sibal urged Venu Srinivasan to acknowledge these legal precedents, stating, "I think that he should step back and make sure there is equitable distribution."
"In a patriarchal society, the father claims to exercise all the rights that may well be vested in his other members of the family. So, he always claims himself to be a patriarch that I am the owner," Kapil Sibal stated.
MoU Interpretation at Core of Disagreement
A key point of contention revolves around a Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) signed by all four immediate family members in March 2024. Venu Srinivasan contends that this agreement settled the division of family interests. However, Lakshmi Venu's legal team disputes this interpretation.
Sibal clarified that Lakshmi Venu's signing of a non-compete arrangement and her subsequent departure from the TVS Motor board pertained to management responsibilities, not a relinquishment of her ownership rights or beneficial interest in the family business. He argued that accepting management roles does not equate to parting with a 50% share of beneficial interest, especially when one sibling allegedly receives a disproportionate 95% of assets.
Karta's Role as Custodian
Responding to Venu Srinivasan's position on self-acquired assets, Sibal distinguished between independently purchased property and assets inherited through a family business. He explained that inherited business assets cannot be willed away by an individual, as children possess equal rights. Sibal reiterated that a Karta (head of a Hindu Undivided Family) acts as a custodian of the family's wealth, not its sole owner, and must account for it.
He firmly stated that a Karta cannot unilaterally decide which child inherits family assets because such property is not personal. This legal distinction forms a central pillar of Lakshmi Venu's claim for an equitable share in the long-standing TVS family enterprise.