Former Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud recently addressed medical students and doctors at the University College of Medical Sciences (UCMS) in Delhi. Speaking at the institution's 55th anniversary event, he issued a stern warning against attempts to destabilize democratic institutions, emphasizing their crucial role in societal survival.
The Imperative of Institutions
Chandrachud asserted that “a society survives by institutions,” a principle he believes is currently under threat from those seeking to undermine foundational structures. He credited institutions like UCMS, Delhi University, and GTB Hospital for shaping professionals and sustaining public trust, highlighting their “critical difference” in fostering excellence.
Lessons from Medicine and Judiciary
Drawing parallels between the medical and judicial professions, Chandrachud noted that while professional success isn't always within an individual's control, the process followed remains their responsibility. He urged doctors to be compassionate communicators, patient, and understanding, recognizing that “every doctor cannot heal” just as “every judge cannot render justice” in every instance due to legal or natural limitations.
He stressed the importance of listening attentively to patients, even when their concerns might appear medically irrelevant, as the patient's perspective is vital to effective care. “The process is as important as the goal,” he added, explaining that while healing may not always be in a doctor's hands, the quality of care and communication certainly is.
AI as an Aid, Not a Replacement
While acknowledging technology as a valuable ally, the former CJI cautioned against allowing artificial intelligence to replace human judgment. He compared evidence-based medicine to judicial principles, stating that AI cannot account for a patient's socioeconomic circumstances or make nuanced judgments on appropriate treatment and human justice. “That no amount of artificial intelligence will tell you,” he remarked, underscoring the irreplaceable role of human empathy and discernment.
Ethics, Patience, and Patient Welfare
Chandrachud called for ethics to be the “heart of our professional life” for doctors, not merely an academic subject. He shared personal reflections on his judicial career, handling numerous cases and emphasizing the necessity of patience and remaining focused on the present moment, referencing the Marathi concept of 'sthitaprajna'.
The former CJI underscored that the patient remains “the soul of the process,” with their dignity and welfare paramount. He also highlighted the importance of protecting medical professionals, referencing the RG Kar Medical College case to illustrate society's debt to doctors regarding their health, safety, and welfare. “Because I believed that for all the work which young doctors do... society owes to doctors... their health, their safety, and their welfare,” he concluded.