Centrum Broking's latest analysis of the metal sector for the second quarter of fiscal year 2027 (Q2 FY27) reveals a mixed bag of performances among key players. While steelmakers largely grappled with declining realizations and elevated input costs, leading to squeezed margins, companies like Hindalco Industries Ltd demonstrated robust growth across their diverse operations.
The brokerage firm anticipates a recovery in operating performance during the second half of FY27 (H2 FY27), driven by seasonal demand, increased volumes, and improved steel realizations. However, it cautions that coking coal and other input costs could remain near-term headwinds.
Steel Sector Faces Margin Pressure
Most ferrous producers experienced a sequential decline in steel realizations, ranging from approximately Rs 1,100 to Rs 2,700 per tonne in Q2 FY27. Jindal Steel was a notable exception, reporting an increase of around Rs 650 per tonne. Volume growth varied, with Jindal Steel leading at about 27% year-on-year (YoY), followed by JSW Steel with 15% growth and Steel Authority of India Ltd (SAIL) at 5%. Tata Steel's consolidated volumes remained largely flat, despite an 8% increase in its standalone business.
EBITDA per tonne generally fell by Rs 1,400-1,800 sequentially for most firms. Tata Steel Ltd, however, saw an improved performance thanks to its Netherlands operations. Jindal Stainless recorded a 1% YoY rise in consolidated EBITDA per tonne but a 6% sequential drop to Rs 21,568.
NMDC's Rising Costs Impact Profitability
NMDC Ltd, a major iron ore producer, saw its production grow by approximately 19% YoY in Q2 FY27, though sales volumes dipped by about 2%. Realizations increased by 10% YoY but decreased by 1% sequentially to Rs 5,488 per tonne. A significant concern was the rise in costs, which climbed to 70.7% of sales, up from 68% in Q2 FY26 and 63.6% in Q1 FY27. This led to a 1% YoY and 12% sequential fall in EBITDA per tonne to Rs 1,853, with margins contracting to 29.3%.
Hindalco Industries Delivers Strong Growth
In contrast to the challenges faced by steel and iron ore miners, Hindalco Industries Ltd reported strong, broad-based growth. Its consolidated EBITDA surged by 43% YoY to Rs 12,800 crore. While Novelis shipments saw a slight 2% YoY decline, higher realizations boosted adjusted EBITDA per tonne by roughly 23%. In India, both upstream and downstream aluminium segments recorded EBITDA per tonne increases of 40% and 9% respectively, supported by better realizations, premiums, and an optimized product mix.
Hindalco's copper business also performed exceptionally, with EBITDA soaring 164% to a record Rs 1,670 crore, though management expects a normalized quarterly run rate of Rs 1,200-1,300 crore. Future growth is anticipated from downstream expansions, additional capacity, captive coal mines for aluminium, and the normalization of Oswego operations alongside the commissioning of Bay Minette for Novelis.
Pipe Makers Show Divergent Trends
Among pipe manufacturers, APL Apollo Tubes Ltd reported strong sales volumes, up 13% YoY and 29% quarter-on-quarter (QoQ), reaching 0.96 million tonnes. Its EBITDA per tonne improved to Rs 6,000, a level management expects to maintain or surpass in Q3 FY27, reiterating a target of approximately 20% EBITDA growth for FY27.
Ratnamani Metals and Tubes saw its standalone revenue recover by 18% after three quarters of decline. However, its EBITDA margin fell to 9.3% from 14.9% a year earlier, with consolidated margins at about 14% partially cushioned by subsidiary performance.
Centrum Broking's Stock Ratings
Centrum Broking has reiterated its 'buy' ratings for several prominent Indian metal stocks, setting new target prices:
- Jindal Steel: Target Price Rs 1,315
- JSW Steel: Target Price Rs 1,370
- Tata Steel: Target Price Rs 215
- Jindal Stainless: Target Price Rs 861
- Hindalco Industries: Target Price Rs 1,150
- Ratnamani Metals & Tubes: Target Price Rs 2,720
The firm has assigned a 'neutral' rating to:
- SAIL: Target Price Rs 170
- NMDC Ltd: Target Price Rs 75
- APL Apollo: Target Price Rs 2,250