Indian author and researcher Rajiv Malhotra has publicly challenged Elon Musk, asking why his Starlink satellite internet service remains blocked in China, despite Musk's substantial investments in the country through Tesla. This query comes amidst a broader controversy surrounding Starlink's delayed entry into the Indian market.
Malhotra's question directly references Musk's earlier cryptic remarks about 'certain oligarchs' allegedly obstructing Starlink's operations in India to maintain a 'monopolistic chokehold.' While Musk initially avoided naming individuals, he later specifically criticized Reliance Industries chairman Mukesh Ambani, a statement that drew a sarcastic 'Welcome to India, Elon' from politician Rahul Gandhi.
Beyond the technological aspects, Malhotra emphasized that the Starlink debate extends to critical issues of national sovereignty. He highlighted concerns regarding the potential for foreign entities to control service access, influence social unrest, and X's (formerly Twitter) past record concerning anti-India content. Malhotra advised Musk against aligning with Rahul Gandhi, suggesting Musk's team might not have fully briefed him on Indian political dynamics.
In response to Musk's allegations, the Indian government has maintained that its regulatory framework for satellite communication is fair and non-discriminatory. It stated that security assessments are ongoing for all three licensed entities, which include Starlink, Reliance Jio's Jio Satcom, and Bharti-backed Eutelsat OneWeb. The government clarified that all licensees are at a similar regulatory stage, awaiting clearance from the Ministry of Home Affairs, a process not specific to any single company.