Search

Cookies

We use cookies to improve your experience. By continuing, you accept our use of cookies.

Business

TMPV Shares Plunge 8% After Q2 Loss; JLR Guidance Cut Prompts 'Sell' Ratings

· · 3 min read

Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles (TMPV) shares dropped 8% following a Rs 5,531 crore Q2 loss. Brokerages Citi and MOFSL issued 'Sell' ratings after JLR cut its FY27 EBIT margin and free cash flow guidance.

Shares of Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles Ltd (TMPV) experienced a sharp decline of 8% in Monday's trading, hitting a low of Rs 263.60 apiece. This significant drop follows the company's reported Q2 loss of Rs 5,531 crore, coupled with a downward revision in guidance for its luxury automotive arm, Jaguar Land Rover (JLR).

Several leading brokerages have reacted bearishly to the news. Citi and MOFSL (Motilal Oswal Financial Services) both issued 'Sell' ratings, setting target prices of Rs 235 and Rs 240 respectively. Jefferies assigned an 'Underperform' rating with a target of Rs 240, while Axis Capital recommended 'Reduce' with a target of Rs 360.

JLR Guidance Cut and Market Challenges

The updated guidance from JLR is a major concern for analysts. CLSA noted that JLR has cut its FY27 Ebit margin guidance from 4% down to 2-3% and its free cash flow (FCF) guidance from breakeven to a negative £1.25 billion. Morgan Stanley highlighted the challenging environment for JLR, pointing out that upcoming model launches are electric vehicles (EVs), where competition is intensifying.

Nuvama further elaborated on JLR's weak performance in FY26, attributing it to several factors: a cyberattack causing production cuts, the discontinuation of Jaguar models, market share loss in China due to fierce competition, and an increase in luxury tax. Tariffs in the US and subdued European demand were also cited as significant headwinds.

India Business and Future Outlook

Despite the current challenges, some analysts see potential for recovery, particularly from the India business segment. Morgan Stanley noted that the bulk of TMPV's stock value comes from its India operations, emphasizing that improvement in profitability (excluding PLI benefits) is crucial to monitor.

Nuvama anticipates a bounce-back for JLR from a depressed FY26 base, driven by production normalization and the launch of new products, including the Range Rover EV, Range Rover Sport EV, Jaguar Type 01 EV, and Range Rover GT. They project an 11% revenue CAGR over FY26–29E and an Ebitda margin expansion from 6.7% in FY26 to 12.2% in FY29E, supported by better scale and cost savings.

Elara maintained an 'Accumulate' rating, expecting the India business to benefit significantly from increasing Battery Electric Vehicle (BEV) penetration, projected to rise from 8% currently to 18% by FY30E. While acknowledging global demand weakness and Chinese competition in the luxury segment for JLR, Elara expects Ebitda margin improvement as new models and cost-reduction initiatives take effect.

Conversely, Investec and CLSA maintained 'Buy' ratings with targets of Rs 380 and Rs 369, respectively, suggesting differing views on the long-term prospects. Goldman Sachs maintained a 'Neutral' rating with a target of Rs 260.

Related